![]() |
Administrators :Ken Cornett | |
| Forum The Common Ground - A Forum For Civil War Reenactors |
Not logged | Login
|
|
| Online:1 guest is browsing the forum | ||
Register |
Profile |
Private messages |
Search |
Online | Help
| Create a free blog | ||
![]() | ||
|
| ![]() | ![]() |
| Author : | Topic: July 18th | Bottom |
| Bill moderator Posts : 1326 The original fence sitter ![]() |
Hood's career in the Confederate Army is the perfect example of the Peter Principle at work. This was a man who was definitely promoted to the level of his incompetentence. | ||||
| Bill Rodman King of Prussia, PA wrodman1@aol.com |
| firstmdes Posts : 11 B&O American Type Locomotive ![]() |
I totally agree with your statement and understand that there was a lot of politics in the military...140+ years ago as well as today. That being said, I wonder how much attrition played a role in the promotion of bad officers. Someone has to lead the large units, so someone has to be promoted, right? Unfortunately, the more officers like Hood were moved up, the more vacancies were made due to deaths caused by bad command decisions (i.e.: the Battle of Franklin). The way my pro-Union eyes see it, it was a good thing Hood was promoted above his level of competence! It helped to restore the Union faster!! | ||||
| John P. Maranto "Independent Reenactor" -- which means, "I rarely get out much these days!" |
| GrumpyDave moderator Posts : 1767 Yes, if I'm registered for the event; expect buckets of rain. ![]() |
There's another notible problem the South had; they kept running out of competent leadership, while the North kept finding more and more. | |||
| GrumpyDave Towsen 6 gum blankets? May not be enough. |
| firstmdes Posts : 11 B&O American Type Locomotive ![]() |
Could the reduction of competent officers in the CSA military be the result of "Confederate honor" requiring the officers to lead from the front? Or is it just a usual attrition problem made worse by the shortage of manpower? | ||||
| John P. Maranto "Independent Reenactor" -- which means, "I rarely get out much these days!" |
| GrumpyDave moderator Posts : 1767 Yes, if I'm registered for the event; expect buckets of rain. ![]() |
Both things you stated compounded the Confederacy's problems, along with a lack of forsight(Mostly because the State governments couldn't agree on just about anything). We have no manufacturing, where will we get the tools of war? We have no navy, how will we protect our coasts and ports? If the war becomes protracted, how will we fill our ranks? We lack good transportation to move and suppy our armies, or to take the war to the North; how will we build more? How will we get foreign aid, we have no allies? The Civil War ended America's Fudalistic Society. WW 1 took care of it in the rest of the world. | |||
| GrumpyDave Towsen 6 gum blankets? May not be enough. |
|
| ![]() | ![]() |
Get a free forum!
AceBoard Free Forum v 5.3
Download Premium Web Templates!