FORUM, Forum Discussion, Forum Gratuit, Nom de domaine, Nom de domaine gratuit, Redirection gratuite,

Forum The Common Ground - A Forum For Civil War Reenactors Administrators :Ken Cornett
Forum The Common Ground - A Forum For Civil War Reenactors
Not logged | Login
Online:2 guests are browsing the forum
Register Register | Profile Profile | Private messages Private messages | Search Search | Online Online | Help Help | Create a free blog

forum Forum index forumEvent Discussion forumOutpost

Author : Topic: Outpost  Bottom
 Bill
 moderator
 Posts : 1387
 The original fence sitter
 Bill
  Posted 29/10/2007 06:14:11 PM
Send a private message to Bill
Hey guys,

How about some grewsome details? From what I'm seeing, it was an excellent event.

Bill Rodman
King of Prussia, PA
wrodman1@aol.com
 Charles Heath
 Posts : 574
 I'd have to work my way up to
curmudgeon
  Posted 30/10/2007 01:05:35 PM
Send a private message to Charles Heath
Bill,

There is a nice AAR thread on the AC Forum.

Charles Heath
Purveyor of finely composted manure and excelsior.
 RJSamp
 Posts : 68
 YCSAIYSOYA You can\'t sell
anything if you\'re sitting
on your a ss!
  Posted 04/11/2007 08:58:49 PM
Send a private message to RJSamp

Quote :

Charles Heath wrote : Bill,

There is a nice AAR thread on the AC Forum.




yes, it's very 'nice'. EVeryone going overboard to pat themselves on the back and play nicey nicey. Doesn't appear that anyone wants to examine the event, provide recommendations that will correct/mitigate the mistakes, and improve the product does it?

RJ Samp
 Ross4thUSInfy
 Posts : 19
  Posted 04/11/2007 10:14:31 PM
Send a private message to Ross4thUSInfy
I believe I would politely disagree with that sentiment = there are several people who have justifiably given honest critique and assesment on that AC thread.  The majority of my comrades had rave reviews, myself included, but as always, others mileage varied.

Ross L. Lamoreaux
Member, SCAR
Ross@ejtmercantile.com
 flattop32355
 Posts : 151
 I used to care what you thought of
me...
 flattop32355
  Posted 05/11/2007 01:03:13 AM
Send a private message to flattop32355
What points would you say needed improvement, RJ?

My perspective comes only from the preliminary activities and from Company B; we were separated from the rest of the battalion except when fighting.

Bernard Biederman
30th OVI
Co. B
 Charles Heath
 Posts : 574
 I'd have to work my way up to
curmudgeon
  Posted 05/11/2007 11:16:11 AM
Send a private message to Charles Heath
Over on the AC Forum OP3 AAR thread, Bernie asked a question Freeman Tilden would love.  

Charles Heath
Purveyor of finely composted manure and excelsior.

forum Forum index forumEvent Discussion forumOutpost
top
Go to :
  Add a quick reply

Add a quick reply